This is the second article in a two-part series on evaluations for children with learning differences. Part one looks at neuropsychological evaluations: what they are, what parents can expect, and when they may be useful. Part two focuses on school-based evaluations and the role they play in identifying a child’s educational needs.

Years ago, when my son was seven years old, his elementary school teacher told me that he’d like to recommend my son for a school-based evaluation. The teacher explained that my son was often out of his seat wandering the classroom while his classmates were working on learning tasks. When my son was sitting at his desk, he often fidgeted or looked around the room, behaviors that kept him disengaged from his schoolwork.

New England Tutors: A Parent’s Guide to School-Based Evaluations At the time, I did not really know what a school evaluation was. Would they be testing my son’s IQ? Were they evaluating his mental health? Were there tests to decipher why my son did not engage with his work? I also did not really understand what the evaluation was for. I was told that school evaluations would not provide a diagnosis (like ADHD or autism), which made me unsure what the tests would accomplish. While I think the school team meant well, somehow I was not able to get the information that I needed. Hearing that your child is not engaging at school in the expected way can also be an emotionally charged time. Perhaps the school team was giving me the information, but I could not process it. Whatever the reason, I wish at the time I’d had a clearer guide to help me understand the process and purpose of a school evaluation.

For this guide, I reached out to Dr. Rebecca Vujnovic, assistant professor and director of the master’s program in school psychology at the University at Buffalo, to help me make sense of the school evaluation process so that other parents would not have to wade through the confusion that I experienced.

Who Gets Evaluated?

Dr. Vujnovic works as a clinical instructor at the University at Buffalo, runs a private practice where she conducts evaluations, and is a New York State licensed psychologist. Not only does she have a wealth of expertise related to school evaluations, in her job at the university she teaches future school psychologists how to conduct school evaluations. Dr. Vujnovic explains that two common concerns may lead families and schools to consider an evaluation.

The first concern involves social-emotional or behavioral difficulties. Some children struggle to manage anger or frustration, leading to meltdowns or outbursts. Others have difficulty regulating attention or maintaining positive connections with peers. These concerns can interfere with participation in the school day.

The second concern involves academic progress. A child may struggle to make expected progress in reading, writing, or math, even with extra instruction. Behavioral and academic concerns can also overlap.

Neither social-emotional or academic concerns would get a child recommended for testing right away. Schools often begin by providing support through general education. A child might receive small-group reading instruction or work with a counselor on social skills. Dr. Vujnovic explains that when these supports are not enough, the school may recommend a formal evaluation. Parents with concerns can also request an evaluation themselves.

What Is the Purpose of a School-Based Evaluation?

The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) gives eligible children the right to a free appropriate public education tailored to their needs; the main purpose of a school evaluation is to determine whether a child’s disability impedes their academic progress to the degree that requires special education services.

Eligibility involves more than identifying a difficulty. The team must determine whether the child meets a disability category under the law and whether that disability warrants specially designed instruction. Educational needs can involve social functioning, communication, or behavior as well as academics. Passing or failing grades alone do not determine whether a child receives special education services.

What Happens During the Evaluation?

The evaluation process begins with a referral, followed by a decision about whether an evaluation is needed and what information to gather. Before initial testing begins, the school must obtain parents’ informed written consent. If your child is referred for an evaluation, you can ask what each assessment will examine and who will conduct it. School evaluations are provided at no cost to families.

Dr. Vujnovic explains that evaluations are tailored to the concerns about the individual child. Testing may examine thinking and reasoning skills, academic skills, or social-emotional functioning. Depending on the child’s needs, specialists might assess speech and language or motor skills.

Testing is only part of the picture. The school psychologist may observe your child in class, and teachers and parents may complete questionnaires or interviews. Your child’s developmental history and previous school experiences also help the team understand what they are seeing.

In New Hampshire, the initial evaluation process generally must be completed within 60 calendar days after the school receives parental consent. If your child is undergoing evaluation, ask when you will receive reports and when the team will meet to discuss them.

How Are Services Decided?

Once the evaluation is complete, a team that includes parents and school professionals reviews the results and determines eligibility. One test score or one evaluator does not make that decision alone.

Parents should bring their questions and perspective to these evaluation meetings. You should prepare to describe what you have observed at home. Dr. Vujnovic also encourages drawing attention to your child’s strengths. Understanding what your child does well can help the team to understand your child holistically and to better plan support.

If your child qualifies, the team develops an Individualized Education Program (IEP). This written plan identifies learning goals and the instruction, services, and accommodations the school will provide. Support may be delivered in the general education classroom; qualifying for special education service does not automatically mean a child will be moved to a separate classroom.

What If My Child Already Has an Outside Diagnosis?

New England Tutors: A Parent’s Guide to School-Based Evaluations A private evaluation may help explain your child’s functioning across settings, but Dr. Vujnovic emphasizes that an outside evaluation and diagnosis do not automatically mean a child qualifies for special education. The school team must still determine whether your child meets educational eligibility requirements. An outside report can contribute valuable information, and sometimes it supplies information that the team needs. Share it with the school and ask how it will inform the decision. The team must consider qualifying independent evaluations, but it does not have to adopt every recommendation.

If your child does not qualify for an IEP, ask about other support. Some children may qualify under Section 504, a separate disability rights law, for accommodations or services, such as extended time on tests. Eligibility here requires its own evaluation; a diagnosis alone does not guarantee a 504 plan either.

A Note Regarding Private Schools

If your child attends a private school, it is important to note that evaluations and special education services will differ from public school. A private school may recommend that your child see a professional for an evaluation, but making that referral does not, by itself, require the school to provide the services or supports the evaluator recommends. Some private schools employ special education professionals or offer additional support, sometimes for a fee; available services vary depending on the private institution. However, attending a private school does not prevent your child from being evaluated through the public school system. Public school districts have responsibilities under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) to identify and evaluate children who may have disabilities, including those attending private schools. Some children whose parents choose private schools may also receive services through the public school district, although they do not have the same individual entitlement to special education services as children enrolled in public schools. Families can contact the public school district that aligns with their home address to ask about evaluations and available services.

Starting the Conversation

You do not need to know your child’s diagnosis to begin. Tell the teacher what concerns you, ask what they see, and discuss support already being provided. If you want a formal evaluation, put your request in writing to the principal or special education administrator and keep a copy. If the school declines to evaluate, it must explain its decision in writing.

Looking back, I wish I had understood that the evaluation was meant to help answer a specific question: does my child need and qualify for special education services? Understanding that purpose would have helped me ask questions and take a more active part in the decisions about his education. Hopefully this report can help orient parents to the evaluation process and help you know what questions to ask should your child need to move through the evaluation process.